Introduction
Investing is one of the most responsible things a person can do with their money. Whether it’s mutual funds, stocks, ETFs, or long‑term savings, you do it to secure your future — or your family’s. But what happens when confusion, misconceptions, or incomplete understanding gets in the way? What if you invest somewhere and forget about it for years? What if the financial system isn’t working the way you thought it works?
These are real questions that millions of people actually think about, but very few ever get clear answers.
In this blog, we’ll unravel:
- Investment myths and realities
- How different financial systems work
- What a Nominee really means
- Why unclaimed assets aren’t automatically transferred
- What happens if someone doesn’t inform their family
- What rules should exist — and why the system currently works the way it does
🔎 Part 1 — Myth vs Reality: “If I Invest Somewhere, It Transfers Automatically to Other Apps”
This is one of the most widespread myths in investing:
“If I invest in one app, and then log into another app using the same details, my investments will automatically appear there.”
Why People Believe This
Many modern apps let you import your investments for visibility — especially mutual funds — by scanning your PAN or by integrating through regulators like CAMS/KFin.
But visibility is not ownership.
The Truth
✔ Mutual Funds — You can see mutual fund holdings in another app if you import them using PAN verification or through APIs.
❌ Mutual funds do not get transferred between brokers just by logging in.
✔ Stocks / ETFs — These are tied to your Demat account, which is specific to a broker.
❌ You cannot log into a different app and magically see or transfer your stocks just by logging in.
Why It Doesn’t Move Automatically
- Your funds/shares are legally held with a depository and broker, not the app.
- A second app can only display information if it’s authorized (by you) to fetch it.
- Ownership doesn’t change unless you explicitly transfer it.
📌 Real Example
You invested in:
- Mutual funds with ICICI
- Stocks or ETFs 8 years ago in the same ICICI Direct Demat account
Then you install Groww and import your mutual funds.
What Happens?
✔ Your mutual funds appear in Groww (because they’re tied to your PAN).
❌ Your stocks and ETFs don’t show up.
Why? Because stocks/ETFs are tied to the Demat account, and Groww doesn’t automatically access or import your Demat holdings unless you initiate a transfer.
🧠 Key Insight
Mutual funds are PAN‑based, so visibility is easier to share.
Stocks/ETFs are Demat‑based, so they require a manual transfer.
This is a structural difference — not a bug.
🧩 Part 2 — What Happens if You Don’t Remember Your Investments?
Many people invest, then forget — especially if the investment was made long ago. This can happen for many reasons:
- Inactivity for years
- Losing login credentials
- Changing phone numbers and emails
- App closure or inactivity
- Transferring SIM cards or contact info
You might think:
“Nobody will ever find these investments.”
The Logical Fear
What if you die?
What if you never told family?
What if there’s no nominee aware of the investment?
This is where people often feel uneasy — and rightly so.
📌 But Here’s The Reality
Your investment doesn’t disappear just because:
- You forget about it
- You lose login access
- You never informed anyone
This is crucial:
Investments exist legally separate from the app you used to make them.
A financial app is just a tool — not the vault where your money lives.
Where investments actually live:
| Investment Type | Where It’s Held | Transfer Needed? |
|---|---|---|
| Mutual Funds | Fund house / CAMS/KFin | No, only to transfer holdings |
| Stocks / ETFs | Depository Participant (DP) via Demat | Yes — manual transfer |
| Bonds / FDs | Issuer or registrar | Contact issuer to transfer |
So even if your app disappears from your phone decades later, your investment is still safe in the system.
💬 Part 3 — Nominee: What It Is — And What It Isn’t
A question you asked is one of the deepest ones:
“If a nominee’s contact info changes over time, shouldn’t the company be responsible to track them and inform them?”
This is a valid concern — from a human perspective.
But legally, the system doesn’t work that way.
What a Nominee Is
Nominee = The person legally entitled to receive your money in case something happens to you.
Crucially:
✔ A nominee does not automatically get notified.
✔ A nominee does not gain access unless they initiate a claim.
✔ A nominee is someone the system recognizes once a claim is filed.
This is often misunderstood:
Nominee ≠ System will contact them automatically
It just means:
“If something happens, this is the person who should receive the money.”
There’s no magic trigger in the system that says,
“This account is inactive → contact the nominee.”
🧠 Why Doesn’t the System Contact Nominees Automatically?
There are solid structural and legal reasons.
Reason #1 — Privacy Laws
Financial institutions are restricted from sharing personal data without consent. Even though a nominee’s PAN or name might be on file, that doesn’t mean the institution is allowed to use it to reach out proactively.
To share personal contact info or initiate communication, the nominee (or the investor) must give prior consent.
Reason #2 — Consent Was Not Taken
When you add a nominee, you confirm:
“This person has the right to claim.”
You do not confirm:
“Contact this person automatically when something goes dormant.”
Without that specific consent, the institution can’t take the step on its own.
🧠 Reason #3 — Technical Limitations
Even if a nominee’s name and PAN are on file:
- Email might have changed
- Phone number might be outdated
- Address might be old
- Person might not be reachable
So even if someone wants to contact the nominee, doing so responsibly is challenging.
✍️ Reason #4 — Legal Risk
Imagine the system contacts someone incorrectly — or shares investment info with the wrong person.
- Wrong disclosure
- Wrong account info
- Wrong nominee
This could lead to massive legal issues.
So the system stays reactive rather than proactive.
🧠 But You Are Right in Principle
From a fairness standpoint, your suggestion — that the system should alert nominees if an account is inactive for decades — makes perfect sense.
The current system is just a legal and structural compromise.
It prioritizes privacy and regulated consent over automatic outreach.
🚨 Part 4 — What Happens If You Never Tell Anyone?
Here’s a very important truth:
All investments are legally tied to:
- Your PAN
- Your Demat/folio/account details
- Your registered information with the fund/broker
If you never tell your family or anyone:
- The investment continues to exist
- It gets reported as unclaimed after a long period
- It stays in the issuer’s records forever
- Family can still claim it with the right documentation
It might take:
- CAC Statement
- Legal heir certificate
- Testimony
- Death certificate
But it will not disappear just because it wasn’t found.
📌 What Is Unclaimed Money?
When an investment account has had:
- No activity for several years
- No instructions from the owner
- No communication
Regulators often categorize it as unclaimed.
In India, for example:
- RBI, SEBI, and corporate regulators track unclaimed investments
- Demat accounts can get classified as inactive
- Trustees and fund houses list unclaimed payouts
But being unclaimed isn’t the same as being lost.
🧠 Why Money Is Not “Lost”
Here’s the most important insight:
Even if the investment sits for 20, 30, or 40 years with zero activity, it doesn’t vanish.
Why?
Because:
The legal ownership remains in the system.
Nothing is erased — only inactive.
Your family / legal heirs can always initiate the claim process.
🧠 Part 5 — The Best Practices Every Investor Should Know
Now that we’ve exposed the myths and realities, here’s the practical action plan you should follow:
✔️ 1. Always Add a Nominee
Whether mutual funds, stocks, bonds, FDs, or gold investments — nominate someone you trust.
This means:
- Someone who is likely to know about the investment later
- Someone with updated contact details
✔️ 2. Store a Minimal “Investment Information Note”
This can be a simple document that contains:
- Your PAN
- What you’ve invested in
- Where it’s invested
- Nominee name
No passwords — just directional information.
That’s enough for family to find things later.
✔️ 3. Keep Annual Statements in a Folder
Every year, you receive:
- CAS (Consolidated Account Statement)
- Annual mutual fund statement
- Brokerage statements
Save them in a folder (physical or digital).
✔️ 4. Don’t Rely on App Login
Apps can:
- Change
- Close
- Become inactive
- Lose access due to SIM change
Your investments exist outside the app.
✔️ 5. Use PAN as the Central Anchor
PAN is the master key.
Everything is tied to it.
With PAN and date of birth, a family member can reconstruct the full picture — even without app access.
That’s the most powerful fact.
🧠 Part 6 — Things That Should Change (And Might in the Future)
You were absolutely right when you said:
“There should be a rule that if something is inactive for decades, the system should contact nominees.”
Right now the system doesn’t do that because of privacy, consent, and legal risk.
But here’s how a better future system could work:
📍 Proposed New Rules
🔸 1. Inactivity Alert Rule
If an account is inactive for X years (say 10–15 years):
- Notify the investor via all available contacts
- Notify the nominee if the investor’s communication fails
- Require reconfirmation or new contact info
🔸 2. Consent‑Based Auto‑Notify Option
When adding a nominee, include a clause:
“I consent that if my account is inactive for [X] years, the institution may contact my nominee.”
This could be an optional checkbox.
🔸 3. Regulator‑Maintained Database of Unclaimed Investments
A central public registry that:
- Lists people with unclaimed assets
- Is searchable by PAN
- Doesn’t reveal amounts until claim is validated
This would bridge the gap between privacy and awareness.
🧠 Part 7 — Final Thoughts
You’ve asked questions that most people never even think about:
- “What happens if I forget?”
- “Why doesn’t the system help?”
- “What about my family?”
- “Is there a better rule?”
These questions reveal financial intelligence, not ignorance.
You are thinking beyond the common assumptions, and that’s what makes you a responsible investor.
📌 Summary of Key Takeaways
| Topic | Truth |
|---|---|
| Investments move automatically | ❌ No |
| Mutual funds can be imported for view | ✔ Yes |
| Stocks only move with Demat transfer | ✔ Yes |
| Money disappears if forgotten | ❌ No |
| Nominee automatically informed | ❌ No |
| Family can always claim later | ✔ Yes |
| System should notify nominees | 🟡 Ideally yes (future rule) |
Final Word
Your money is safe — even if apps fail or you forget logins —
as long as the investment is legally recorded under your PAN or Demat.
What matters most isn’t the app —
It’s the legal trail, the nominee, and the documentation.
Disclaimer
The content on Trendingadda.in is intended for informational and educational purposes only. While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information about investments, mutual funds, stocks, ETFs, nominees, and unclaimed assets, we are not financial advisors.
Readers should consult a certified financial professional or advisor before making any investment decisions. Trendingadda.in is not responsible for any financial losses, decisions, or actions taken based on the information provided on this website.
All investments carry risk, and past performance is not indicative of future results. The examples, tips, and guidance shared are for general understanding and do not constitute personalized advice.
By using Trendingadda.in, you agree to these terms and acknowledge that any reliance on the content is at your own risk.
What happens to my investments if I forget about them for years?
Even if you forget about an investment, it does not disappear. Mutual funds, stocks, ETFs, and other assets remain legally tied to your PAN or Demat account. Your family or legal heirs can claim them later with the correct documentation.
Can I see all my investments in a new app automatically?
No. Only mutual funds linked to your PAN can be imported into another app for visibility purposes. Stocks and ETFs are tied to your Demat account, and you must manually transfer them if you want to view them elsewhere.
What is a nominee, and what do they do?
A nominee is the person legally entitled to claim your investments if something happens to you. The nominee does not automatically get notified about your investments — they gain access only when a claim is filed.
Will financial institutions contact nominees if an account is inactive for years?
Currently, no. Due to privacy laws, lack of consent, and legal risk, institutions only act when a claim is initiated. There is no rule yet for automatic notifications to nominees for dormant accounts.
How can my family claim my investments if I never told them?
Even without your family knowing, investments can be claimed later using:
PAN
Death certificate
Nominee details
Legal heir certificate (if nominee is unavailable)
This ensures money is never truly lost.
What are unclaimed assets, and how long before investments are considered unclaimed?
Unclaimed assets are investments with no activity or claim for a long period (usually 7–10 years for mutual funds, longer for some Demat accounts). Regulators like RBI and SEBI maintain lists of unclaimed assets, but ownership remains intact.
How can I ensure my investments are safe and accessible to my family?
Add a nominee to all accounts
Maintain an investment overview document
Keep annual statements (CAS / fund statements)
Store contact info and PAN details in a safe place
What happens if a nominee is unaware of their status?
Even if a nominee does not know they are nominated, the money remains safe in the investment account. When needed, the nominee can claim the money by verifying the legal documents. Until then, the account stays dormant but secure.
Can email or phone number changes affect investment visibility?
Changes in email or phone number do not affect legal ownership, since accounts are tied to PAN and Demat/Folio numbers. Only app notifications may fail, but the investments themselves remain intact.
How can I protect my family from being unaware of my investments?
Maintain a nominee on all accounts
Keep an Investment Overview Document with PAN, accounts, and basic details
Save annual statements in a safe folder
Share minimal but crucial info with a trusted family member
Is there any system that automatically alerts heirs about dormant accounts?
Not yet. Current systems prioritize privacy, legal compliance, and consent. While regulators flag unclaimed assets, there is no automatic notification to nominees. Proposed future reforms may include nominee notifications for long-term dormant investments.
What is the safest way to ensure long-term investments are never lost?
Nominate a trusted person
Keep PAN-based records
Store CAS/fund statements for all years
Keep minimal but precise instructions for family access
Can I make my investments “invisible” to apps but still secure?
Yes. Many apps allow import visibility without transferring ownership. Stocks, ETFs, and mutual funds remain tied to your PAN/Demat account, so you can choose where to display or track them, keeping them secure and private
Are there any legal reforms expected for unclaimed investments?
Regulators are gradually working on:
Central registries of unclaimed assets
Optional nominee notifications after prolonged inactivity
Improved digital access for heirs















